Texas Dentists for Medicaid Reform

NEW PHONE NUMBER
For more information call (512) 487-7584

  • Home
  • Issues
  • * Medicaid Difficulty Alert *
    • About the Medicaid Difficulty Alert
    • Alert Form
  • Articles
    • TDMR articles
    • Medicaid Media
    • Compliance Articles
  • Archive
    • The Facts About the Medicaid Orthodontic Scandal 2007 to 2012
    • Antoine Dental Case
    • HHSC-OIG Archive 2012 to 2014
      • TMHP
      • Harlingen Family Dentistry Case
        • Further HFD articles
      • OIG Never Returns Funds
      • Webinar March 19 2012
      • 2008 TMHP Audit by OIG
      • 2012 TMHP Audit by OIG
      • OIG Legislative Testimony
        • OIG Testimony March 19 2013
        • OIG Testimony February 13 2013
        • OIG Testimony February 4 2013
        • OIG Testimony January 30 2013
      • Jack Stick Arrest for DWI
    • Due Process Archive
      • Survey Results
      • Committees
        • Hearing Videos
      • TDMR Submission
      • HB 1536/SB 785
        • House Committee on Human Services
        • Written Testimony
        • Attorney Testimony Videos
        • Dental Provider Testimony Videos
      • SB 1803
        • Overview
        • Bill Moves to House
        • Public Testimony Videos
        • Passes House Committee
        • Bill Changed Before House Vote
        • SB 1803 Has Passed the House!
      • Other Proposed Bills
      • Due Process Legal Articles
      • Legislative Media
      • Media Archive
  • About
    • Dr. Juan D. Villarreal
    • Dr. Paul Dunn
    • Gregory Ewing
  • Contact
You are here: Home / Media / Hospitals Received Millions in Excessive Outlier Payments Because CMS Limits the Reconciliation Process

Hospitals Received Millions in Excessive Outlier Payments Because CMS Limits the Reconciliation Process

November 29, 2019 By TDMR Leave a Comment

Why OIG Did This Review
Outlier claim payments are based on hospital cost reports from the latest cost-reporting period for which the cost report is either settled as final or tentatively settled. The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) requires its Medicare administrative contractors to reconcile outlier payments by using information from the updated current cost-reporting period, but only if the cost report meets the following criteria: the actual cost-to-charge ratio (CCR) is found to be plus or minus 10 percentage points from the CCR applied during the payment period (10-percentage-point threshold), and the outlier payments in that cost reporting period exceed $500,000.

From fiscal years 2011 through 2014 (4-year period), CMS made more than $18 billion in outlier payments to 3,336 hospitals that submitted 13,344 cost reports (3,336 × 4 cost reports). Of these hospitals, 972 submitted 3,888 cost reports that had outlier payments exceeding $500,000 for each year, and 3,863 of those cost reports with outlier payments, totaling $14.7 billion, did not meet the 10-percentage-point threshold for reconciliation.

Our objective was to determine whether CMS paid hospitals more for Medicare outlier payments than the hospitals would have been paid if their outlier payments had been reconciled.

How OIG Did This Review
We used the claims data, information from CMS, and cost reports for a 4-year period to recalculate outlier payments based on the actual CCRs of 60 hospitals that had received $3.5 billion in outlier payments. We also analyzed CCRs of 912 hospitals that received $11.2 billion in outlier payments. We estimated the potential costs to Medicare Administrative Contractors (MACs), as well as the potential return on investment, of reconciling the 236 cost reports that did not meet the 10-percentage-point threshold.

What OIG Found
From fiscal years 2011 through 2014, CMS paid the 60 hospitals a net of $502 million more in outlier payments than the hospitals would have been paid if their outlier payments had been reconciled. (We refer to this net amount as excessive outlier payments.) Specifically, CMS paid 53 hospitals $541 million more than they would have been paid and 7 hospitals $39 million less than they would have been paid over the 4-year period. CMS did not detect or recover these excessive outlier payments because the 236 associated cost reports did not meet the 10-percentage-point threshold for reconciliation.

The cost reports associated with these outlier payments did not meet CMS’s 10-percentage-point threshold for reconciliation because when hospitals increased their charges at a rate higher than the rate of cost increases, this usually resulted in only a small percentage point change in their CCRs. Of the 236 cost reports of 60 hospitals that we reconciled, 216 (92 percent) had a change of less than 5 percentage points in their CCRs. In addition, 34 of the 60 hospitals received excessive outlier payments each of the 4 years in our 4-year period. Of the 3,627 cost reports that we did not reconcile but for which we determined the differences between CCRs used at the time of claim payments and the actual CCRs, 3,417 (94 percent) had a change of less than 5 percentage points in their CCRs. CMS set the 10-percentage point threshold, because it believed that the threshold would appropriately capture those hospitals whose outlier payments would be substantially inaccurate when the hospital uses the ratio from the contemporaneous cost-reporting period. Based on the estimated time and costs that we received from 7 MACs, we estimate that the administrative burden on the MACs to reconcile the 236 cost reports that did not meet the 10-percentage-point threshold would be a minimum of $47,200 and a maximum of $1.7 million for 4 years, or a minimum of $11,800 and a maximum of $425,000 per year.

What OIG Recommends and Auditee Comments
We recommend that CMS require reconciliation of all hospital cost reports with outlier payments during a cost-reporting period. If this had been in effect for the 60 hospitals in our review, CMS would have saved approximately $125 million per year. In written comments on our draft report, CMS concurred with our recommendation and stated that it is evaluating the current outlier reconciliation criteria and will consider whether to propose any appropriate modifications to the outlier reconciliation policy in future rule making.

Complete Report | Report in Brief

Source: Hospitals Received Millions in Excessive Outlier Payments Because CMS Limits the Reconciliation Process / U.S. Department of Health and Human Services Office of Inspector General

Share this:

  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)
  • Click to print (Opens in new window)
  • More
  • Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Tumblr (Opens in new window)

Filed Under: Media Tagged With: Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, HHS-OIG

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Search the TDMR Website

Most Viewed Posts & Pages

  • Fort Worth Doctor Sentenced to 10 Years in Health Care Fraud Conspiracy
    Fort Worth Doctor Sentenced to 10 Years in Health Care Fraud Conspiracy
  • Dental firm managers accused of health care fraud
    Dental firm managers accused of health care fraud
  • Spine surgeon gets 10-year prison sentence for healthcare fraud
    Spine surgeon gets 10-year prison sentence for healthcare fraud
  • Three companies receive Medicaid managed care dental contracts
    Three companies receive Medicaid managed care dental contracts
  • Judge Orders Dr. Richard Malouf to Pay Texas Back $12 Million for Medicaid Fraud
    Judge Orders Dr. Richard Malouf to Pay Texas Back $12 Million for Medicaid Fraud

Receive Updates on TDMR Activities

Recent Comments by Readers

  • mattthew on Texas Lawyers Behind Samson Dental Partners and ImmediaDent $5.1 million settlement in Indiana
  • Spence on Woman claims dentist pulled wrong tooth
  • Spence on Woman claims dentist pulled wrong tooth
  • Nilar Vargas on Dentists cleared to administer COVID-19 vaccine in California
  • TDMR on UPDATE: Dentists Clarified as Healthcare Workers to Receive COVID-19 Vaccines
  • Angela on UPDATE: Dentists Clarified as Healthcare Workers to Receive COVID-19 Vaccines

Recent Media of Interest

Dental firm managers accused of health care fraud

February 26, 2021

Spine surgeon gets 10-year prison sentence for healthcare fraud

February 26, 2021

Fort Worth Doctor Sentenced to 10 Years in Health Care Fraud Conspiracy

February 26, 2021

U.S. Attorney Scott Brady and Pennsylvania Attorney General Josh Shapiro Announce Indictment in Nursing Home Investigation

February 25, 2021

AG Healey reaches settlement with Brighton dental office for failing to accept MassHealth patients

February 24, 2021

Feds: Father, son sentenced in $27M Obamacare scheme

February 24, 2021

Mhiramarc Exec Sentenced in $28 Million Hospice Fraud Scheme

February 22, 2021

HHS Acting Secretary Norris Cochran Declares Public Health Emergency for State of Texas Due to Winter Storms

February 19, 2021

President Biden Announces Key Members of his Health and Human Service, Education, and Veterans Affairs Teams

February 19, 2021

Feds sweeten Medicaid deal

February 19, 2021

Senior Care Company Agrees to Pay $714,996 to Resolve False Claims Act Allegations

February 18, 2021

Three companies receive Medicaid managed care dental contracts

February 17, 2021

Medical equipment firm and its owner agree to pay $20.3M in fraud scheme

February 17, 2021

Biden’s Medicare Pick Would Be 1st Black Woman to Hold Post

February 17, 2021

15 years in prison for $154 million Medicare fraudster

February 15, 2021

Former top aides say Attorney General Ken Paxton received assistance with home remodel, job for alleged girlfriend in return for helping political donor

February 12, 2021

More Articles...

Copyright © 2021 · All Rights Reserved. Texas Dentists for Medicaid Reform · Privacy Policy