Texas Dentists for Medicaid Reform

NEW PHONE NUMBER
For more information call (512) 487-7584

  • Home
  • Issues
  • * Medicaid Difficulty Alert *
    • About the Medicaid Difficulty Alert
    • Alert Form
  • Articles
    • TDMR articles
    • Medicaid Media
    • Compliance Articles
  • Archive
    • The Facts About the Medicaid Orthodontic Scandal 2007 to 2012
    • Antoine Dental Case
    • HHSC-OIG Archive 2012 to 2014
      • TMHP
      • Harlingen Family Dentistry Case
        • Further HFD articles
      • OIG Never Returns Funds
      • Webinar March 19 2012
      • 2008 TMHP Audit by OIG
      • 2012 TMHP Audit by OIG
      • OIG Legislative Testimony
        • OIG Testimony March 19 2013
        • OIG Testimony February 13 2013
        • OIG Testimony February 4 2013
        • OIG Testimony January 30 2013
      • Jack Stick Arrest for DWI
    • Due Process Archive
      • Survey Results
      • Committees
        • Hearing Videos
      • TDMR Submission
      • HB 1536/SB 785
        • House Committee on Human Services
        • Written Testimony
        • Attorney Testimony Videos
        • Dental Provider Testimony Videos
      • SB 1803
        • Overview
        • Bill Moves to House
        • Public Testimony Videos
        • Passes House Committee
        • Bill Changed Before House Vote
        • SB 1803 Has Passed the House!
      • Other Proposed Bills
      • Due Process Legal Articles
      • Legislative Media
      • Media Archive
  • About
    • Dr. Juan D. Villarreal
    • Dr. Paul Dunn
    • Gregory Ewing
  • Contact
You are here: Home / Medicaid Reform News / Law Firm Representing Qui Tam Relator Sued for Malpractice

Law Firm Representing Qui Tam Relator Sued for Malpractice

July 31, 2020 By TDMR 13 Comments

At the end of April, a three-judge panel of the Fifth District Court of Appeals in Dallas ordered a malpractice lawsuit against the firm of Sommerman McCaffity Quesada & Geisler and Al Ellis, of counsel at the firm, to continue. The case against the attorneys had been thrown out last year by a Dallas District Court judge, and the Court of Appeal sent the case back to that court to continue.

Lawyers for qui tam case

This case is of interest because three of Sommerman McCaffity Quesada & Geisler partners, Andrew Sommerman, Tex Quesada and Sean McCaffity, currently represent qui tam whistleblower, Joshua Lafountain, in his TMFPA lawsuit against 71 Medicaid dental entities and dentists for which he has never worked.

Case alleges bad legal advice

Per the Court of Appeal decision, the malpractice case revolves around legal advice given to a family whose home burned to the ground in late 2009 in which the wife had died. The family had hired the Sommerman firm and Ellis to bring a product liability suit against the manufacturer of the clothes dryer in the home, which was apparently the cause of the blaze. 

The Sommerman attorneys hired experts, but 11 days before trial, Ellis advised the family to settle for $800,000 of which his firm got 40% because, as he told them in an email, “we cannot win an appeal because no expert can testify as to the cause of the fire and without that we don’t stand a chance. I wish it were different but unfortunately the law is not on our side.”

After the settlement, to give themselves some peace over the tragedy, the family hired its own expert to find the cause of the blaze. The expert was able to determine that the cause was undeniably the gas valve of the dryer.

So afterwards, in 2017, the family brought the malpractice suit against the Sommerman firm and Ellis and asserted “claims of negligence, gross negligence, breach of fiduciary duty [later non-suited], and violation of the DTPA [Deceptive Trade Practices Act].” 

Unfortunately, the husband passed away after the filing leaving the son and the parental estates to pursue the claims.

For full reference, please read the Court of Appeal’s decision available for download below.

Motion in qui tam case to dismiss and sanction Sommerman attorneys

In the qui tam case which is currently before a judge of the Dallas District Court, as already reported by TDMR, lawyers for one of the defendant dentists has filed a motion asking the judge presiding over the case to dismiss it and sanction the whistleblower and his lawyers, the Sommerman partners mentioned previously as well as two lawyers from Passman & Jones.  

The motion calls the qui tam lawsuit “groundless, brought in bad faith and for the purpose of harassment” because Lafountain’s testimony under oath in a deposition given in April “contradicts and disproves allegations in his pleadings as well as representations previously made by Relator’s counsel to the Court.” 

Specifically, the motion states:

  • Relator does not currently have any evidence to support any TMFPA claim against any Defendant;
  • Relator (and his counsel) filed this lawsuit without a good faith basis, in violation of Texas law;
  • Relator is using this lawsuit as a tool to investigate theoretical claims, which is beyond the qui tam authority delegated by the Texas Legislature; and
  • Relator’s discovery requests are fishing expeditions prohibited by Texas law.

OAG refuses to dismiss case

Despite these glaring deficiencies, the Civil Medicaid Fraud Unit of the Office of the Attorney General, which has the power to dismiss such cases, refuses to do so.

The agency had even filed a brief with the court that “there is no provision of the TMFPA that requires the qui tam relator to have “independent” “direct” or “first-hand” or “insider” knowledge of any alleged unlawful conduct.”

Based on this assertion, the Office of the Attorney General will support any qui tam lawsuit against any Medicaid provider, no matter how unfounded or ridiculous the allegations, if the relator can find a law firm with the ethics to pursue a “groundless, brought in bad faith and for the purpose of harassment” legal action. 

Healthcare providers deserve better

Healthcare professionals deserve better treatment from their government.

court of appeal brief

Share this:

  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)
  • Click to print (Opens in new window)
  • More
  • Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Tumblr (Opens in new window)

Filed Under: Medicaid Reform News, Slider Tagged With: medicaid fraud, medicaid whistleblower, texas medicaid reform

Comments

  1. SD says

    July 31, 2020 at 3:25 pm

    Healthcare professionals deserve better treatment from their government!!! They’re going through enough and should not be dragged through the mud based on groundless claims!!! Wasting everyone’s money that can be used to treat kids in need.

    Reply
  2. E.F. says

    July 31, 2020 at 3:27 pm

    Knowing what the rumors are about this Lafountain character, it is no surprise that a shady law firm like this is the one to take this insane case. I guess we shouldn’t be surprised that the Attorney General who is under indictment is leading a Attorney Generals office who openly allow obvious and blatant shakedowns for money. This is absolutely disgusting. I hope it boomerangs back on them all.

    Reply
  3. Pete M says

    July 31, 2020 at 4:39 pm

    I can not believe this case has not been dropped. The whole situation stinks and seems like the system is crooked. OAG needs to dismiss this case and go after the real crooks here which clearly are the plaintiffs and the lawyers. We need to put an end to this injustice.

    Reply
  4. Ss says

    July 31, 2020 at 9:45 pm

    This is the ultimate representation of bad faith legal practices. The pursuit of justice and truth are what our courts are supposed to provide. Baseless claims and insufficient evidence has to be looked at and attorneys must be sanctioned. Criminal behavior

    Reply
  5. Daniel K. says

    July 31, 2020 at 10:37 pm

    Seems like the AG just wants a win on his resume, even if it’s at the cost of innocent doctors. This is the most disgusting thing I’ve heard of, reminds me of corrupt prosecutors you see in the news. Definitely loosing hope in the “justice” system

    Reply
  6. JH says

    August 1, 2020 at 1:12 pm

    It’s absolutely unbelievable that the attorney general allows these people to extort dentist, NOT to mention allow healthcare providers to be treated this way. Whatever happened to upholding “the oath of office”? How are crooked lawyer allowed to operate like this? Why isn’t there more community support for innocent healthcare providers dealing with situations like this?

    Reply
  7. Gloria Marr says

    August 1, 2020 at 4:37 pm

    The level of corruption within the judicial system here is so blatantly apparent in this case. I’ve been following all the related posts on tmdr. It’s pretty clear that the Judge is in on it with the lawyers. Not only should the case be dismissed, the corrupt judge should be disbarred. Such an embarrassment for state of Texas and stain on the reputation of AG.

    Reply
  8. Lisa B says

    August 1, 2020 at 4:40 pm

    Breaking news !
    Personal Injury lawyers who pay and support judges to extort dozens of companies using a witness with no first hand knowledge are sued in another case for not being moral nor ethical …
    Sadly that makes sense
    I wish it didn’t so much sense in today’s climate
    We deserve better
    Not worse

    Reply
  9. A Giavelli says

    August 1, 2020 at 5:29 pm

    These guys should be disbarred. Top to bottom corruption, Backdoor deal with judges and a spineless and corrupt AG. This is supposed to be the United States and Texas dammit. Where doctors and professionals and businesspeople have a fair shot and are held in high regard, not ostracized and sought after in a witch hunt. AG will be joining the unemployment statistics soon, and the lawyers will be disbarred. We won’t stand for this!

    Reply
  10. Bill H. says

    August 1, 2020 at 5:29 pm

    It’s not surprising that Joshua Lafountain’s law firm is getting sued. The fact they are representing this crook in this cash grab shake down is appalling.

    Reply
  11. Ben says

    August 1, 2020 at 5:55 pm

    How are these lawyers and attorney general allowing this to happen. This is a mockery of our system. The ag should be protecting dentists not conducting a witch hunt based on some guys claims with no evidence

    Reply
  12. Iknowjoe says

    October 18, 2020 at 9:30 pm

    You recently posted a new article on Lafountain and the AG and it was retracted. Was it Ken Paxton or the leach attorneys that caused this?

    You obviously hit a sensitive spot! Don’t back down!

    Reply
    • TDMR says

      October 19, 2020 at 3:13 am

      No, there was a verification problem that arose and we couldn’t justify publishing the article within our standards. Appreciate your support.

      Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Search the TDMR Website

Most Viewed Posts & Pages

  • Dental firm managers accused of health care fraud
    Dental firm managers accused of health care fraud
  • Fort Worth Doctor Sentenced to 10 Years in Health Care Fraud Conspiracy
    Fort Worth Doctor Sentenced to 10 Years in Health Care Fraud Conspiracy
  • Spine surgeon gets 10-year prison sentence for healthcare fraud
    Spine surgeon gets 10-year prison sentence for healthcare fraud
  • Feds: Father, son sentenced in $27M Obamacare scheme
    Feds: Father, son sentenced in $27M Obamacare scheme
  • Three companies receive Medicaid managed care dental contracts
    Three companies receive Medicaid managed care dental contracts

Receive Updates on TDMR Activities

Recent Comments by Readers

  • mattthew on Texas Lawyers Behind Samson Dental Partners and ImmediaDent $5.1 million settlement in Indiana
  • Spence on Woman claims dentist pulled wrong tooth
  • Spence on Woman claims dentist pulled wrong tooth
  • Nilar Vargas on Dentists cleared to administer COVID-19 vaccine in California
  • TDMR on UPDATE: Dentists Clarified as Healthcare Workers to Receive COVID-19 Vaccines
  • Angela on UPDATE: Dentists Clarified as Healthcare Workers to Receive COVID-19 Vaccines

Recent Media of Interest

Dental firm managers accused of health care fraud

February 26, 2021

Spine surgeon gets 10-year prison sentence for healthcare fraud

February 26, 2021

Fort Worth Doctor Sentenced to 10 Years in Health Care Fraud Conspiracy

February 26, 2021

U.S. Attorney Scott Brady and Pennsylvania Attorney General Josh Shapiro Announce Indictment in Nursing Home Investigation

February 25, 2021

AG Healey reaches settlement with Brighton dental office for failing to accept MassHealth patients

February 24, 2021

Feds: Father, son sentenced in $27M Obamacare scheme

February 24, 2021

Mhiramarc Exec Sentenced in $28 Million Hospice Fraud Scheme

February 22, 2021

HHS Acting Secretary Norris Cochran Declares Public Health Emergency for State of Texas Due to Winter Storms

February 19, 2021

President Biden Announces Key Members of his Health and Human Service, Education, and Veterans Affairs Teams

February 19, 2021

Feds sweeten Medicaid deal

February 19, 2021

Senior Care Company Agrees to Pay $714,996 to Resolve False Claims Act Allegations

February 18, 2021

Three companies receive Medicaid managed care dental contracts

February 17, 2021

Medical equipment firm and its owner agree to pay $20.3M in fraud scheme

February 17, 2021

Biden’s Medicare Pick Would Be 1st Black Woman to Hold Post

February 17, 2021

15 years in prison for $154 million Medicare fraudster

February 15, 2021

Former top aides say Attorney General Ken Paxton received assistance with home remodel, job for alleged girlfriend in return for helping political donor

February 12, 2021

More Articles...

Copyright © 2021 · All Rights Reserved. Texas Dentists for Medicaid Reform · Privacy Policy